Salmon, sea bream, hamachi – more than half of all fish and seafood worldwide now comes from aquaculture. This comes as no surprise: global overfishing is currently one of the most serious threats ocean health and marine life. At the same time, demand for fish and seafood continues to rise. Aquaculture is therefore part of the solution – but only if it is managed responsibly.
This is where the ASC seal comes in. But what does it really stand for? Can you truly enjoy ASC-certified farmed fish with a clear conscience? And what do environmental organizations criticize? We explain it – honestly and transparently.

What is the ASC seal - and who is behind it?

ASC stands for "Aquaculture Stewardship Council" – an independent, non-profit organization founded in 2010 by WWF and the IDH Initiative. It certifies fish and seafood from aquaculture that has been independently audited against environmental, social, and animal welfare standards.
Headquartered in Utrecht, the Netherlands, the ASC works with independent certification bodies worldwide, relying on a third-party certification system. The goal: to ensure that aquaculture can fulfill its potential as a responsible and sustainable food source and to reduce – or ideally eliminate entirely – the negative impacts of the global aquaculture industry. This is because aquaculture, when poorly and irresponsibly managed, can cause significant problems such as water pollution, destruction of mangrove forests, or antibiotic misuse.

Today, over 24,000 consumer products worldwide carry the ASC label, and more than 2,020 farms are certified.

Important: The ASC label is the counterpart to the MSC label for wild-caught fish. Both labels complement each other and cover different areas of fish production. At HONEST CATCH, we deliberately offer both MSC- and ASC- certified products.

How does ASC certification work?

ASC certification does not follow an "once registered, forever certified" principle. Instead, independent, accredited certification bodies, also known as "conformity assessment bodies," verify whether a farm or supply chain company meets the relevant standards. A team of social and technical auditors inspects farms on-site under the supervision of an experienced assessor during a certification process that typically lasts four to six months.
To ensure that the public is sufficiently involved, interested external parties and affected communities are actively encouraged to submit comments and feedback on the farm. All comments must be addressed by the assessor and taken into account in the decision-making process.

Once certified, a farm is considered ASC-certified for three years. During this period, annual audits ensure that the standards continue to be met. If requirements are not filfilled, the certificate can be revoked. Full traceability throughout the entire supply chain is mandatory – from hatchery to final packaging on the supermarket shelf.

Criticism of the ASC seal: What you should know

The ASC seal was developed through negotiations between environmental organizations, industry, and retailers – and can therefore be considered a compromise solution between various interest groups. The main points of criticism: the permitted use of genetically modified soy and the not entirely prohibited use of fishmeal and fish oil as feed.
An important point of context: according to the WWF, predatory fish like salmon cannot be entirely switched to a vegetarian diet due to biological constraints. This is not a political decision – but a scientific limitation. However, ASC-certified operations must demonstrate that their fishmeal is sourced from sustainably managed fisheries and is fully traceable.

Our honest assessment: the ASC label is not a free pass. But completely ignoring certification labels generally leads to less informed purchasing decisions.

Conclusion: The ASC seal as a solid foundation

The ASC label is the best-known and most widely used standard for farmed fish and seafood. It independently and regularly checks environmental impact, social responsibility, farm management, and animal welfare.
At the same time, it is not a premium label. The criticism of fishmeal and genetically modified soy is justified. But: a well-designed compromise standard is better than none at all.

Our advice: Use the ASC seal, as well as the MSC seal, as a first guide. But also look at the supplier: those who provide transparent information about origin and production methods, who openly address weaknesses, and who invest in innovation – they earn your trust.

Frequently asked questions about the ASC seal

What does ASC-certified mean?

ASC-certified means that the aquaculture farm your fish comes from has been audited by an independent body against environmental sustainability, social standards, farm management, and animal welfare, and has met these requirements. Certification must be renewed regularly. It applies exclusively to farmed products – not to wild-caught fish.

Is ASC-certified fish truly sustainable?

ASC-certified fish is often produced more sustainably than farmed fish without certification. According to ASC, the standards are based on scientific evidence. However, there is valid criticism, for example regarding the permitted use of genetically modified soy. The label is a useful indicator, but not a free pass.

What is the difference between ASC and MSC?

The ASC label applies to fish and seafood from aquaculture (farmed fish). The MSC label applies to wild-caught fish. Both labels were developed at the initiative of the WWF, follow similar principles, and complement each other. At HONEST CATCH, we deliberately carry products with both certifications.

How do I recognize the ASC label when shopping?

The ASC label is a turquoise-green logo featuring the letters "ASC" and a small fish. You'll find it on the packaging or in our online shop on the product images and in the product description.

Annika

AUTHOR

Annika from HONEST CATCHAs Social Media & Content Manager, Annika is always on the lookout for the latest trends and viral moments. Whether it's sushi ice cream or dumpling lasagna, good food always comes first.

Last updated: 22.04.2026